The New York City music scene of the late 1980's and early 1990's is
inevitably referred to as a "family" by anyone who played there or saw a show
by any of the various up-and-coming bands of the era. From local bands God
Street Wine, Joan Osborne and Jono Manson to touring bands Widespread Panic,
Phish, Aquarium Rescue Unit and others, they all knew and respected each other,
and cross-pollination ran rampant at their shows. However, the two bands most
frequently associated with one another were Blues Traveler and the Spin Doctors.
The two would play the same local bars on the same schedule, often hitting the
same venues on different days within the same week. Blues Traveler landed a
regular gig at the Wetlands Preserve while the Spin Doctors held down a spot
at Nightingale's. In a 1998 interview, Chan Kinchla, when asked about the
shows, remembered them fondly. "We used to play the same places near each other
and the crowd would go back and forth when one band's set ended. One time one
of us ran down to the Spin Doctors' gig and played with them, and it eventually
got to the point where one night we'd all go there, take their places one by
one, and then they'd go back to where we had been playing and end up playing
there for the rest of the night! Eventually we started booking gigs together
and playing that way."
While this may have been a common occurrence in the years preceding it,
May 26th, 1990 is the first recorded full-band segue between the two
bands. On the date in question, the two bands shared a bill at the Marquee
in New York City. The Spin Doctors began their set with Turn It Upside
Down, played six songs, and then launched into a lengthy Shinbone
Alley>Forty or Fifty segue. In mid-song, members of Blues Traveler began
joining the Spin Doctors crew on stage and turning the song into a
double-band jam. As the groove continued, Spin Doctors members began
leaving the stage, and gradually the laid-back Forty or Fifty slowly
morphed into the head-on rush of Trust in Trust. The jam ended two songs
later, after a high-speed Crash Burn>Wouldn't It Make You Mad?, and the
music never stopped. Amazingly, the two bands traded three more sets this
way, segueing from Blues Traveler back to the Spin Doctors and back to
Blues Traveler again, encoring with a raucous eight-person take on Johnny
B. Goode. Such shows apparently occurred up through a 1994 tour which took
both bands to the United Kingdom, but with the decline of the Spin Doctors
and the outward-looking tour schedule of both bands, such shows have now
disappeared from both bands' radar.
More about the Spinning Traveler phenomenon can be found in this quote from the
Official FAQ:
Much can be said about the relationship between BT and the Spin Doctors.
Many rumors abound and much hullabaloo has been made over the weird
pupa-like state in a show involving the two bands . What this is really
all about involves the truest singular connection between them and that is
the musical one. Both bands having known each other for so long as well as
having mastered the art of segueing one song into the next had naturally
taken the next logical step segueing into each other. For example, the
Spin Doctors will be playing Shinbone Alley, as the jam progresses, John
Popper comes out and starts soloing and trading riffs with Mr. Schenkman.
Then Chan Kinchla will come on stage as the jam starts to take on eclectic
possibilities. Soon Bob Sheehan will comes out and trade bass tones with
Marc White. As this is happening, Brendan Hill will start tinging and
pinging Aaron Comess' cymbals. The key of this jam may shift at this point
as needed, and at some point no one knows exactly where, Brendan is now
sitting down and it is Aaron Comess who is tinging and pinging. Once he
leaves, the groove is decidedly different, everyone's still going at full
blast. As member of Spin Doctors leave the stage, it is becoming apparent
that this jam is sounding more and more like But Anyway. Before you know
it, BT finishes up But Anyway and are now well into their set. If you go
to the bathroom, or even look down for a minute, you could miss it and
many are the strange reports from fans who swear they were watching the
Spin Doctors only realize they had been dancing to BT the whole time. This
effect can cause not only disorientation, but a nervous, queasy feeling
for those unprepared. A feeling that perhaps they aren't really who they
were to begin with, but someone else entirely, and that they had been this
person for most of their life, only now realizing that their parents had
given birth to, and raised someone else. Be careful, when at these shows
to accept who you actually are because you cannot sue yourself, though
many have tried. It doesn't matter that much now because the bands have
grown so differently from those special days that you probably can relax
in relative comfort, confident that you weren't that guy standing next to
you. Whether that is a good thing or a bad thing, is up to you.
Spinning Traveler gigs
- 08/23/89 Wetlands Preserve, New York, NY [no setlist available]
- 05/26/90 The Marquee, New York, NY
- 08/18/90 Blues Bake '90, Roger Baldwin Park, Greenwich, CT
- 08/19/90 Surf Club, South Hampton, NY
- 10/31/90 The Marquee, New York, NY
- 11/27/90 Cornell University, Ithaca, NY
- 12/31/90 Roseland Ballroom, New York, NY
- 06/21/94 SFX Center, Dublin, Ireland
|